Pages

Friday, July 12, 2013

NYS Residency and the Professional Athlete

by Brian Gordon, CPA

“This article originally appeared in the July 2013 TaxStringer and is reprinted with permission from the New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants.”


Residency for state tax purposes has proven to be a very difficult concept to comprehend. This is quite understandable given all the factors state taxing authorities use to determine domicile, as well as related court decisions. While the issue is complicated enough for any taxpayer, it becomes especially confusing when residency rules are applied to the life of a professional athlete. What kinds of issues will tax professionals have to handle with clients employed by a team in a professional sports league?
New York state determines residency in one of two ways:
  • Domicile: People are residents of New York if they are domiciled there. In a legal sense, "domicile" simply means a person’s primary residence.
It's not a clearly defined issue: Domicile is an issue of intent. People can choose where they want to live, but they must choose and actually live there. (It is well settled that “[t]o effect a change in domicile, there must be an actual change in residence, coupled with an intention to abandon the former domicile and to acquire another” according to Matter of Ingle, Tax Appeals Tribunal, December 1, 2011, quoting Aetna Natl. Bank v. Kramer, 142 AD 444 [1911]). They must have the feeling that the new place is their “home”—a place that they will return to when they are absent. The burden is upon any person asserting a change of domicile to show that the necessary intention existed. There is no bright line test as in statutory resident (below). It requires an analysis of several factors to determine if the requisite intent was actually exhibited.
  • Statutory Resident: According to the law, someone would be a resident if he or she maintains a permanent place of abode (residence) in New York state, and is present in the state for more than 183 days. The same rule applies for New York City resident tax.
Someone could be a resident of two states for tax purposes, by being domiciled in one state, and a statutory resident in another. Good planning could help to avoid that troublesome situation.
Many states have the same or similar laws as New York. Because athletes travel so much, and they are not often in one location for the majority of the year, the primary issue generally is domicile—where they claim is their fixed and permanent home.
The typical audit question would be: Is the athlete domiciled at the primary location of the team that employs him or her (home field), or at an off-season residence in a different state or country?
To determine domicile, the New York audit guidelines require examination of five primary factors. There are also secondary and other factors which may or may not play an important role in domicile determination. This list is not in order of importance because the importance varies depending on the individual circumstances, as becomes clear in more detailed examination of the rules, below.
  • Home: Comparison of residences and how they are used—lifestyle.
  • Business: Location of business involvement or employment.
  • Time Spent: Amount of days spent at each state of residence.
  • Items Near and Dear:  Location of cherished possessions.
  • Family Ties: Relationship to close family members.
"Lifestyle," although not listed in the guidelines as a separate factor, permeates all of the factors. Domicile cases that have been heard in court have analyzed it in detail. Lifestyle can mean how people spend their time. What do you like to do, and with whom? What are your hobbies? At which of your residences to you carry out most of these activities?
The business factor is also important for athletes. Most people live near where they work. This can also be true for a professional athlete; however athletes have a different work pattern and lifestyle than most employees.
The athlete has the following work pattern and lifestyle:
  • The season—when they play for a good part of the year. During the season, they play half, or more, of their time at their team’s “home” city/state (home games), and the other portion visiting the cities of their opponents (away games). Many athletes will have a residence (or permanent place of abode) near their home team location.
  • Playoffs. If an athlete's team qualifies for the playoff tournament, the season is extended until the team is either eliminated or wins the championship. This again consists of home and away games.
  • A pre-season—where the team trains to get ready for the new season. This can be located in a state different from the “home” state.
  • An off-season—where athletes have no work responsibility for a few months. Many athletes will also have a residence in a state or country that is far from their home team location for the off-season. This off-season location may be where they grew up, or it may be a location that they chose as an adult.
There are no guarantees in life, but a teacher who takes a new job in a new location probably changed domicile. A professional athlete’s life is generally not as stable as that of a teacher. Athletes rarely get to choose which team they play for, or how long they play for that team. An average career is less than five years, according to various studies. A player may be on two or three different teams during that time. Taking a new job in a new city (going to a new team) would just be the beginning of a domicile analysis. All other factors would have to be analyzed to determine if an athlete intended to make this new location a fixed and permanent home.
There was a case in New Jersey, Matter of Samuelsson, where the athlete, a hockey player, prevailed in his claim of a change of domicile from New Jersey to Florida, when he changed teams from Philadelphia to Tampa Bay (Tax Court of New Jersey Kjell And Vicki Samuelsson, Docket No. 003615-2004).
There was also a case in New York, Matter of Meminger, in which a basketball player was found not to have changed domicile when he changed teams from New York to Atlanta (New York State Tax Commission - File No. 24810).
New York and New Jersey have the same basic residency laws. It all depends on the individual facts. Most of the court cases on athletes’ residency are very old, as the more recent audits have been resolved without going to court.
Let’s look at another factor: time spent at each location. This is also generally a very important factor because you usually spend most of your time at your primary residence. Although this seems like common sense, it is not necessarily the case for professional athletes.
Because of the length of a professional sports season, players may spend more time in their team’s home state than in any other location; however, their lifestyle may indicate more of a fixed and permanent association with their off-season home. On the other hand, it may not. Each person’s situation is different.
Home: Are homes owned or rented? What is the size and value? Which one does the athlete intend to be a permanent home? How does an athlete use a home? Is it furnished and decorated as a permanent home, or more of a temporary residence?
Family: Who are the athletes' close family members? Are they married? Do they have children? Where do they primarily reside? Where do their children go to school?
Near and dear items: Where do the athletes keep their prized possessions— for example, Super Bowl rings or Olympic medals? These may be monetarily valuable items, or items with only sentimental value.
All of these factors will help to determine where the domicile is—the place that an athlete's actions point to as the intended permanent home.
This does not mean that athletes must stay at a location for 30 years or any other defined period of time. The requirement is only that at the time that they move there, or at any other future time, they decide that this is the place that they intend to make their primary home. It becomes the focus of their life with regard to family, friends, leisure activities—lifestyle—and that the residents intend that home to be a permanent home, "with the range of sentiment, feeling and permanent association with it." (As described in Matter of Bodfish v. Gallman.)
Allocation of Income: Another state tax issue for athletes to be concerned with is allocation of income. After a residence in a state is chosen or determined, the athlete must pay tax to all other states in which they perform—that is by playing in a regular season game, playoff game, pre-season game, practice, or any other team meeting or team responsibility. The same applies to other team members, such as managers, coaches and trainers.
For all of these issues mentioned—domicile, statutory residence and income allocation—knowing the amount of time spent in each state or country is important. In the event of a state tax audit, tax auditors will request detailed records of an athlete's whereabouts each day of the year. It’s a burdensome task for an athlete to prove, particularly in the off-season, because there's no team schedule to rely on. It is also valuable during the season if games are missed due to injury, because the team schedule may not be applicable to you during the injury.
Athletes and their tax advisors must give very careful consideration to the above-mentioned factors to determine which state they are a resident of for state tax purposes, and which states they must report income to as a nonresident. As with any other tax issue, for best results it is best to be prepared for an audit before it happens.
Meanwhile, the way athletes are taxed remains subject to debate, as noted in a pair of "Tax Compass" articles in the April Tax Stringer.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
For a free phone consultation on this or any other tax issue or concern please call
Brian Gordon, CPA at (516) 510-6041 or email at bgord520@gmail.com.

Brian Gordon, CPA, is a state and local tax consultant in private practice. Previously, he was with the NYSDTF for more than 30 years, most recently as a District Audit Manager in Manhattan and Brooklyn, where he was involved in many residency audits of professional athletes. He is a member of the NYSSCPA New York, Multistate & Local Taxation Committee and writes and speaks on various tax issues. He can be reached at 516-510-6041 or bgord520@gmail.com. He also posts a monthly blog at http://gordonstate.blogspot.com.

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

NYS Nonresident Wage Allocation: No De Minimis Rule

by Brian Gordon, CPA
“This article originally appeared in the May 2013 TaxStringer and is reprinted with permission from the New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants.”
 
You're a nonresident of New York state who works just one day in the state in a given year. Are you still subject to income tax in New York? Yes. Even one day makes you liable for taxes: There is no de minimis rule for nonresident income tax. New York State Department of Taxation and Finance Technical Memorandum TSB-M-12(5)I, issued July 5, 2012, explains the tax department’s policy.
 
Actually, there is a de minimis rule—but it's for employer withholding, not for the employees paying taxes. Consider  nonresident employees  assigned to a primary work location outside of New York.  If they work 14 days or less in New York, the employer is not required to withhold New York tax for that employee. In that case however, the employees are still required to file a New York nonresident income tax return and allocate the appropriate portion of their wages to New York based on the days worked within and outside of New York, and pay any tax due. The employees are also responsible for estimated taxes if warranted.

There are exceptions to the de minimis rule, however. The 14-day rule for withholding does not apply to compensation paid to nonresident traveling salespersons or other employees when the compensation depends entirely on the volume of business they transact. In these cases, the employee’s income is not earned evenly across the number of days worked like a salaried employee; the amount earned in New York in a few days, based on business transacted, may be a significant number—not de minimis.

Compensation paid in one year that is related to services performed in a prior year also does not qualify for the 14-day rule. Examples of this would be deferred compensation and compensation from nonstatutory stock options. Because this income was earned in prior years, the employer would be required to withhold New York taxes based on the days worked in and out of New York in the years the income was earned. For deferred compensation, generally you would use the last three full years worked plus the most recent partial year, as a basis for the allocation. For nonstatutory stock options, the allocation period is option grant date to vest date. This was the result of a rule change in 2006.
Other situations where the 14-day de minimis rule does not apply involves employees that can earn a very high income for one day of work. Withholding, and of course income tax, is required for the following types of taxpayers, even if they work only one day in the state:

Public Speakers
This includes those who earn income from public speaking and personal appearances. It is not limited to income earned from services in the form of a speech, presentation or personal appearance.

Professional Athletes
It should be noted that the allocation method for professional athletes’ wages has changed over the years. At one time, athletes’ wages were allocated based simply on the number of games in a regular season schedule, plus playoffs (this means games that count, not practice or exhibitions) played in New York, divided by the total number of games. Now, earnings are allocated by work days, or what New York calls “duty days.”Duty days include all days that the athlete is required to be at work, including pre-season games, practice and workouts.

Interestingly enough, the New York Giants football team is based in New Jersey. In most years, they do not play any games in New York (unless they play against the Buffalo Bills, in Buffalo, which last happened in 2007); however, they have held their training camp in New York. The salaries of the nonresident players, coaches and others with the team are therefore subject to NYS withholding and income tax based on the number of duty days practicing in New York. (More on this issue can be found in the Tax Compass section of the April 2013 Tax Stringer.)

Entertainers
This includes, but is not limited to, actors, singers, musicians, dancers, circus performers, writers, directors, producers, set designers, and any person appearing on television, radio, the stage, a night club performance or hotel show. In short, anyone who received compensation related to a live, recorded or filmed performance in New York state. (References to specific parts of state tax law that cover nonresident withholding and taxation can be found in the technical memorandum.)

For a free phone consultation on this or any other tax issue or concern please call
Brian Gordon, CPA at (516) 510-6041 or email at bgord520@gmail.com.







Wednesday, April 24, 2013

File a Protective Claim for New York State MCTMT by April 30, 2013

If you are a self-employed individual, and timely filed the annual Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax Return, MTA-6 for tax year 2009, the deadline to file a protective claim is quickly approaching.  That date is April 30, 2013.  You only have to file a protective claim once.  It will apply to all open and all future periods. 

If you are an employer, and filed the MCTMT quarterly return MTA-305, and have not filed a protective claim for previous quarters, you also have the deadline of April 30, 2013, to file a protective claim for the quarter Jan. - March 2010.  As with self-employed annual filers, the claim will apply to all open and all future periods. 


You are advised to file a protective claim, because the constitutionality of the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax has been challenged.  It is very easy to do so. 
Just click on the link Protective Claim to get started.

 

First, let me make it clear that until this issue is resolved in the courts, the MCTMT is still in effect and must continue to be filed. 


Responsibility of employers: 

The MCTMT on employers is determined on a quarterly basis. If wages subject to withholding for covered employees exceeds $312,000 for a quarter, MCTMT is due for that quarter.  Employers file form MTA-305.  If in a following quarter, covered employee wages does not exceed $312,000 MCTMT is not due for that quarter.  


Covered employees are those whose predominant responsibilities, base of operations or direction and control is in the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation District (MCTD).  If any of these are not conclusive, then the employees’ residence should be used.


 
The (MCTD) includes the counties of New York (Manhattan), Bronx, Kings (Brooklyn), Queens, Richmond (Staten Island), Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Orange, Rockland, Putnam and Dutchess. 
Quarterly MCTMT returns must be filed and any MCTMT due must be paid for each calendar quarter by the last day of the month following the end of the quarter as follows:

Quarter                                                          Due Date

 January 1 to March 31                                    April 30

April 1 to June 30                                            July 31

July 1 to September 30                                   October 31

October 1 to December 31                             January 31 

MCTMT payments – The method and due dates for remitting MCTMT payments depend on whether or not the employer is required to or elects to participate in the PrompTax program for New York State withholding tax purposes. 

Responsibility of Self-Employed Individuals (including partners in partnerships and members of LLCs that are treated as partnerships for federal income tax purposes):

If you are a self-employed individual (as defined above) with net earnings from self-employment allocated to the MCTD in excess of $50,000 you are subject to the tax (MCTMT). 

Net earnings from self-employment is generally the amount computed on federal Form 1040, Schedule SE, Section A, line 4 or Section B, line 6 depending on which section you are required to complete. 1

 
If you have net earnings from self-employment allocated to the MCTD from more than one business or partnership, you must use the total of all your net earnings from self-employment allocated to the MCTD for purposes of the $50,000 threshold and to compute the tax.  

 
Please note that this $50,000 threshold is an allocated number.  That is total net income allocated to the MCTD by use of allocation methods according to NYS Personal Income Tax rules (Not NYS Corporation Tax rules). 

Annual MCTMT returns (MTA-6) for self-employed individuals is due on or before the 30th day of the fourth month following the close of the tax year (for calendar-year filers, this will be April 30 of the following tax year).  

Individuals who will owe any MCTMT for the tax year must make estimated MCTMT payments. The estimated tax payments are due quarterly. 

Quarter                                                          Due Date

 
January 1 to March 31                                     April 30

April 1 to June 30                                             July 31

July 1 to September 30                                   October 31


October 1 to December 31                             January 31 

All MCTMT filings and payments may be web filed through the Tax Department website or paper filed with check remitted.
 
 
According to the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance website:

 
The constitutionality of the MCTMT has been challenged in a series of lawsuits. In all but one of these lawsuits in which there has been a decision, the MCTMT has been ruled to be constitutional and the legal challenges have been dismissed. In just one of the challenges, a Nassau County Supreme Court justice recently found the MCTMT to be unconstitutionally enacted, which determination is being appealed by the State of New York and the MTA. The litigation is not concluded and the tax is still in effect. If this requirement to pay the tax and file returns were to change, the department will notify taxpayers. 

All taxpayers who have been paying this tax remain subject to the tax and are required to continue to pay the tax and file the required returns. As with other taxes, failure to make the tax payments and file required returns could subject a taxpayer to penalties. 

For more detailed information on the requirements for the MCTMT, see NYS Publication 420 – Guide to the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation Mobility Tax. 

For a free phone consultation, call Brian Gordon, CPA at 516-510-6041.

Brian Gordon, CPA, is a state and local tax consultant in private practice. Previously, he was with the NYSDTF for more than 30 years, most recently as a District Audit Manager in Manhattan and Brooklyn. He is a member of the NYSSCPA New York, Multistate & Local Taxation Committee and writes and speaks on various tax issues. He can be reached at bgord520@gmail.com or (516-510-6041).   
He also posts a monthly blog called Brian Gordon's STATEments at http://gordonstate.blogspot.com.
 

1: www.tax.ny.gov

 
 

 



Wednesday, March 20, 2013

YOGA IS SPIRITUAL...THEREFORE NOT SUBJECT TO NEW YORK SALES TAX

This past year, New York issued guidance on the subject of whether Yoga or Pilates classes are subject to sales tax.  They issued NYT-G-12(1)S which is an informational statement of the Department's interpretation of the law, regulations, and Department policies. 

The crux of the guidance involved whether a Pilates and/or Yoga studio constitutes a “weight control salon, health salon, or gymnasium” which would subject it to the local sales tax under Section

11-2002(a) of the Administrative Code of the City of New York (Administrative Code).   

The guidance gave the following information:

A gymnasium is commonly understood to be an indoor facility where sporting and/or exercise activities take place. According to this guidance, Pilates classes constitute exercise activities, therefore the facility would be considered a gymnasium, and the services are subject to sales tax.

However, they concluded that instruction in yoga is not an exercise activity because yoga generally includes within its teachings not simply physical exercise, but activities such as meditation, spiritual chanting, breathing techniques, and relaxation skills. 

If the facility has both Pilates and Yoga, all of the sales of services at the facility are subject to sales tax because the facility is considered a gymnasium.  If the use of the facility is exclusively to teach yoga forms and techniques, the facility will not be considered a weight control salon, health salon, or gymnasium. Therefore, the charges for yoga instruction by this facility are not taxable.

Brian Gordon's STATEment:
I find this guidance to be very generous to the yoga industry.
From my research and experience, I have found that not all yoga classes involve meditation and chanting.  Yoga primarily involves strenuous exercise. I also found that pilates, similar to yoga involves breathing and relaxation techniques, and also involves strenuous exercise.  If you check NYT-G-12(1)S you will see that this guidance came about at the request of a business that offers both pilates and yoga at most of their facilities.  This is not surprising given the similarity of the two forms of exercise. 

What makes the guidance more puzzling is that while yoga is not taxable in a facility by itself, it becomes taxable if offered in a facility that also offers pilates.  What about pilates and a dance class?  Both taxable?  Yoga and a dance class? Both not taxable? 

While New York Tax Laws and policies are sometimes perplexing, it is most important to know what these rules are, so that we are able to comply with them, or if under audit, we know how to defend our position. 

For a free phone consultation on this or any other tax issue or concern, please call
Brian Gordon, CPA at (516) 510-6041 or email at bgord520@gmail.com.


Brian Gordon, CPA, is a state and local tax consultant in private practice. Previously, he was with the NYSDTF for more than 30 years, most recently as a District Audit Manager in Manhattan and Brooklyn. He is a member of the NYSSCPA New York, Multistate & Local Taxation Committee and writes and speaks on various tax issues. He can be reached at bgord520@gmail.com or (516-510-6041).   
He also posts a monthly blog called Brian Gordon's STATEments at http://gordonstate.blogspot.com.ance or audit issue feel free to call Brian Gordon, CPA at 516-510-6041 or email at bgord520@gmail.com.





 

 

Friday, February 15, 2013

NYS Residency: New Domicile Case: Matter of Cooke


“This article originally appeared in the February 2013 TaxStringer and is reprinted with permission from the New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants.”

 
The Cooke Case
by Brian Gordon

In June 2012, the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance issued new Nonresident Audit Guidelines, which it posted on its site. As noted in earlier articles, these guidelines seemed to indicate a new perspective on how the department would be approaching the complex and controversial issue of state residency for income tax purposes. A new case, decided late in 2012, gives some additional insight into the department's current approach toward residency.
In the Matter of the Petition of Gordon R. and Jennifer L. Cooke, issued November 15, 2012, an administrative law judge (ALJ) found that the petitioner (Gordon Cooke) changed his domicile from New York City to the Hamptons on the east end of Long Island, N.Y. This is a very interesting case because a residence used primarily on weekends and holidays was found to be the domicile. Of special interest to CPAs and the clients they serve are the factors outlined in the Audit Guidelines and the facts in this case which led to findings in favor of the taxpayer.
Background: Residency and Domicile Definitions
To understand Cooke, there's a need to know the basic New York residency rules: People are residents of New York if they are domiciled there. "Domicile" in simple terms is a person’s primary residence. Someone would also be a resident, commonly referred to as a Statutory Resident, if he or she maintains a permanent place of abode (residence) in New York state or New York City and they are present in the jurisdiction for more than 183 days. The focus of Cooke is on domicile.
It's not a cut-and-dried decision: Domicile is an issue of intent. That is, people can choose where they want to live, but they must choose, and actually make a change. They must have the feeling that the new place is their “home”—a place that they will return to when they are absent. The burden is upon any person asserting a change of domicile to show that the necessary intention existed.
According to the 2012 NYS Nonresident Audit Guidelines, there are five primary factors the state will consider in analyzing whether a house is a "domicile." None of them stand alone. They all must be analyzed to reach a proper conclusion.
The five primary factors are:
Home: This is a comparison of the residences. The state compares the (1) size, (2) value and (3) nature of use (lifestyle). The most important of these three is "nature of use." In a case such as Cooke, where the issue was between one residence in the city and one in the suburbs, the state looks at what type of life the resident was leading. Is the focus of the resident's life family, friends, holidays, social engagements, sports? Where do those activities take place?
Business Connection: Where you work is important in determining domicile. However, those with resources may decide to keep an apartment near their job and use it like a hotel, while being domiciled in the suburbs where the focus of their life is.
Near and Dear Items: This refers to important tangible items that most people would want to keep with them in their home. They include family photos, collectible items, family keepsakes, documents, trophies and awards, valuable artwork and other valuable items. It is not necessarily the monetary value of these items that will be considered as there are many people that can afford to decorate their homes with very expensive items, but it is the sentiment attached to these items that make them part of one’s primary home. (This has particular meaning in Cooke, noted below, as children's artwork was limited to one of the family's homes, as discussed below.)
Time: This is a calculation of the time spent at each location. This could be a major factor if it is heavily skewed in one location; however, if there is only a small difference, then the other primary factors will be more heavily evaluated.
Family: The state elevated this in the 2012 guidelines to be a primary factor analysis. Family has played such an important role in domicile cases that it could not be overlooked. See Matter of Buzzard (Tax Appeals Tribunal, February 18, 1993, confirmed 205 AD2d 852, 613 NYS2d 294 [3d Dept 1994]). The family factor also played an important role in Cooke.
Finally, "Lifestyle," or “habit of life,” while not specifically enumerated as a primary factor, is interwoven throughout the factors.
The Cooke Case: How the Factors Were Applied
Gordon Cooke conceded that he was domiciled in New York City from 1975 through 1984. In late 1984, the family completed construction of a home at Merchants Path, Bridgehampton , New York—the Hamptons region (the "Merchants Path House"). The Cookes completely furnished the entire home with new items, spending more money than they had ever spent furnishing their New York City apartment. This is part of the home factor analysis, including nature of use.
The Cookes also moved an abundance of their valuable and cherished possessions out of the New York City apartment and into the Bridgehampton house. These included their deceased parents’ papers, a family bible and extensive stamp collection, valuable Curtis Indian prints, Greg Perillo pen and ink drawings, and their children’s artwork, photographs, awards, trophies, and yearbooks. This is included in the analysis of near and dear items and shows a shift to the Hamptons.
In 1983, the family joined St. Ann’s Episcopal Church in Bridgehampton and both of the children were baptized there two years later. Since then, the family has been very involved in activities at the church and regularly attends Sunday services. Both daughters served as acolytes at St. Ann’s when they were younger. The Cookes did not belong to any church in New York City. This evidences the family's lifestyle.
Between late 1984 through 1995, the family's weekly routine typically commenced with a drive to New York City from Sagaponack with his family on Sunday evenings. The family spent Monday through Friday residing in the New York City apartment. During the workweek, Gordon Cooke spent the great majority of his daytime hours working in New York City. Meanwhile, Jennifer Cooke (wife and mother) took care of the children and began taking classes in the city. Once they attained the proper age, the children attended private schools in New York City during this period. The children were very active in scholastic athletics, but did not entertain many friends or socialize while in New York City. On Fridays, the Cookes would drive back out to their Merchants Path House, where they would spend the weekend.
During this nine-year period, the Cookes spent the majority of their free time at their Merchants Path House. Besides spending weekends, they celebrated most holidays there. Additionally, the family hosted many parties for family and friends at the Merchants Path House. They also enjoyed many birthdays and other major family occasions there, such as a tenth wedding anniversary and Jennifer Cooke’s 40th birthday. During this period, such occasions were seldom, if ever held in the New York City apartment. The children participated in extracurricular activities in the Bridgehampton area and later obtained summer jobs there. These are primarily home and lifestyle issues, and show a strong attachment to the Hamptons home and area.
The Cookes filed New York City resident personal income tax returns through 1995. Although Gordon Cooke claims to have been domiciled outside of New York City since 1985, he was required to file as a “Statutory Resident” because he maintained a residence in the city and was present there for more than 183 days. (The facts state that he spent Sunday night through Friday in New York City. Six days per week totals 312 days for a year. Even considering holidays, vacations and business trips, he obviously conceded that it was more than 183 days.)
Business Factor Changes—and an Audit
There was a change in the “Business Factor” near the end of 1995. At that time Gordon Cooke became president and CEO of J.Jill Group/D.M. Management (J.Jill), which is headquartered in Quincy, Massachusetts. Upon joining J.Jill, his primary business activity was no longer in New York City. He remained as president and CEO of J.Jill through May 2006.
In order to accommodate his new work venue, Gordon Cooke rented an apartment in Boston, and stayed there during the workweek. After discussion with his wife, Gordon Cooke chose not to relocate his family to Boston with him because the children were already established in their schools in New York City.
In 2002 (the beginning of the audit period), the Cookes decided to sell the Merchants Path House and buy a new house on Parsonage Pond Road, Sagaponack, New York (Parsonage Pond House)—also in the Hamptons. The Parsonage Pond House was much larger than the Merchants Path House, being approximately 5,500 square feet in size, and cost $3.6 million. Although their children were grown by that time (aged 24 and 19), the Cookes wanted to purchase a larger Hamptons house because, as they testified, they envisioned growing old there together and hosting their children’s families. Lauren Cooke, one of the daughters, described the Parsonage Pond House as her parents’ “dream home.” This is an obvious boost to the home factor in the Hamptons.
During the audit period, daughter Lauren was also working at J.Jill and living in Boston, and daughter Erica was at Brown University in Rhode Island. Jennifer continued her weekday classes in the city, but their daughters’ bedrooms in the city were converted for other functions after their departures. Lauren and Erica Cooke each have a bedroom at the Parsonage Pond House, containing all of their treasured personal memorabilia from their childhood. Lauren explained that she still stays in that room when she visits her parents.
Gordon Cooke testified that since his retirement from J.Jill in May 2006, he has spent more time than ever at the Parsonage Pond House. In addition, he and his wife continue to host parties and holidays there. They stated that they plan to remain in the Hamptons for the remainder of their lives. This is proof that they had the required intent to make this their home.
As a result, the Cookes were able to make the following case for the residency audit years of 2002 to 2004:
Home: Large “dream home” in Hamptons compared with “utilitarian” apartment in the city. Hamptons home used for family gatherings, social events, lifestyle hobbies. The city apartment was used for occasional business trips—no social events.
Business: Primarily Massachusetts. Occasional business trip to the city.
Near and Dear: All precious items and important documents were kept in the Hamptons.
Time: Time in Hamptons and city were about equal. However, Gordon Cooke went to the Hamptons to relax and live his lifestyle, while the city time was primarily work.
Family: While he saw his wife in the Hamptons and the city, Gordon Cooke saw his daughters only in the Hamptons.
Despite this summary, the New York City Audit Division argued that the Cookes' claimed Hampton's home was nothing more than a “weekend/vacations Hamptons lifestyle.”
The government's position may have had more strength prior to the audit period—that is, when Gordon Cooke was still working in New York City, rather than Massachusetts. However, the ALJ didn’t differentiate, citing the Tribunal case Matter of Craig F. Knight (Tax Appeals Tribunal, November 9, 2006), indicating that someone can maintain a residence and work in the city while being domiciled in the suburbs. As noted in Knight:
The presence of a suburban commuter at work or play in New York on most days, without more, does not create a New York domicile and the frequency of theater attendance or restaurant meals seems to have little probative value on the issue of whether his or her home continues to be in the suburbs. If other factors indicate that an individual is a mere sojourner whose home is elsewhere, that status will not be elevated to domicile by the frequency of visits.
The Cooke ALJ further stated that the audit position had ignored the evidence in this case of the "overwhelming amount of family activities and general habit of life that took place in the Hamptons throughout the calendar year." Regardless of whether he was working in New York City or Boston, the Hamptons was the place to which Gordon Cooke intended to return whenever he was absent.
During years in question, 2002 to 2004, while it was true that Gordon Cooke's time in the Hamptons was primarily on weekends, he was spending most of his weekdays in Massachusetts because his job was there. Since he had severed his main business tie with New York, and his daughters had moved out of the city apartment, home base for the family was the Hamptons.
Also according to the ALJ: Both Gordon and Jennifer Cooke and their daughter, Lauren, "testified credibly at the hearing. Each declared their unbridled affection for the Hamptons and stated that it was their home prior to, during, and after the years at issue."
The Cookes did not consider the New York City apartment their home. When asked to compare his feelings for New York City with those for the Hamptons, Gordon described the city apartment as “utilitarian,” whereas “the Hamptons was for life and remembrance.” Lauren [daughter] candidly testified that she did not think of the city apartment as her home, but stated that she “had a specific purpose for being in New York City” and likened her time there to being at a job.
While the standard is subjective, the courts and the Tax Appeals Tribunal have consistently looked to certain objective criteria to determine whether a taxpayer’s general habits of living demonstrate a change of domicile.
In this case, the ALJ stated: Examination of Gordon Cooke's “general habit of life” during the years prior to and including 2002 through 2004 further substantiated the claimed domicile change. In essence, Gordon was an "extremely busy executive who traveled extensively and returned to the Hamptons whenever he did not have somewhere he had to be."
Based on the ALJ’s analysis of the case, it is clear that the family factor, which the state Nonresident Audit Guidelines elevated in importance in 2012, played a significant part in this decision. This decision also showed the importance of not only school-aged children, but of the role of the children as adults, and how that is part of one’s lifestyle.
It may be difficult to make a clear and convincing case for a change of domicile to a home used primarily on weekends, holidays and vacations. Nevertheless, Cooke shows it can be done when residents can prove that the new claimed domicile is the focus of life with regard to family friends, leisure activities—lifestyle—and that the residents intend that home to be a permanent home, with the range of sentiment, feeling and permanent association with it.


For a free phone consultation on this or any other tax issue or concern please call
Brian Gordon, CPA at (516) 510-6041 or email at bgord520@gmail.com.


Brian Gordon, CPA, is a state and local tax consultant in private practice. Previously, he was with the NYSDTF for more than 30 years, most recently as a District Audit Manager in Manhattan and Brooklyn. He is a member of the NYSSCPA New York, Multistate & Local Taxation Committee and writes and speaks on various tax issues. He can be reached at bgord520@gmail.com or (516-510-6041).